Suggestions by @eleanordunkin

Joseph Mawle

as Harold Godwinson in Norman Conquest Revision

Score: +1

Rufus Sewell

as Harold Godwinson in Norman Conquest Revision

Score: -1

Gilles Lellouche

as Duke William of Normandy in Norman Conquest Revision

Score: +1

Jason Sudeikis

as Mr. Peanut Butter in Live Action Bojack Horseman

Score: -2

Jeremy Irons

as Leland Bloom in Open Heart

Score: +1

Kris Bowers

as Composer in Open Heart

Score: +1

Kristen Bell

as Composer in Open Heart

Score: -1

John Mulaney

as Declan Nash in Open Heart

Score: +1

Thandie Newton

as Harper Emery in Open Heart

Score: -1

Shonda Rhimes

as Producer in Open Heart

Score: +1

Jesse Williams

as Tobias Carrick in Open Heart

Score: +1

Sonoya Mizuno

as June Hirata in Open Heart

Score: +1

David Gandy

as Ethan Ramsey in Open Heart

Score: +1

Simone Ashley

as Jackie Varma in Open Heart

Score: +1

Kyla Pratt

as Ines Delarosa in Open Heart

Score: +1

Karrueche Tran

as Kyra Santana in Open Heart

Score: +1

Rosario Dawson

as Harper Emery in Open Heart

Score: -1

William Shewfelt

as Rafael Aveiro in Open Heart

Score: +1

RJ Cyler

as Elijah Greene in Open Heart

Score: +1

Tyler Chase

as Landry Olsen in Open Heart

Score: +1