Suggestions by @eddiekaspbrak

Chosen Jacobs

as Derek Feldman in Scream 1-6 recast

Wes Bentley

as Hank Loomis in Scream 1-6 recast

Jane Krakowski

as Pauline Fleming in Heathers: The Musical

Angourie Rice

as CiCi Cooper in Scream 1-6 recast

Logan Shroyer

as Steven Orth in Scream 1-6 recast

Cameron Britton

as Kenny Brown in Scream 1-6 recast

Brandon Perea

as Dewey Riley in Scream 1-6 recast

Jonah Hauer-King

as Emmett Forrest in Legally Blonde Musical

Kyla Stone

as Elle Woods in Legally Blonde Musical

Georgie Farmer

as Dwayne in The Lost Boys

Michelle Williams

as Lucy in The Lost Boys

Judah Lewis

as David in The Lost Boys

Walker Scobell

as Sam Emerson in The Lost Boys

Jack Champion

as Michael Emerson in The Lost Boys

Avantika

as Star in The Lost Boys

Lizze Broadway

as Sam in Until Dawn

Billy Bob Thornton

as Grandpa Emerson in The Lost Boys

Aidan Turner

as Count Adhemar in A Knights Tale

Oona Chaplin

as Christiana in A Knights Tale

Eva Noblezada

as Jocelyn in A Knights Tale