Suggestions by @drpepper
879 suggestions
Kevin Kline
as Ronald Reagan in American Crime Story: Rawhide Down
Score: +4
John Carroll Lynch
as James Brady in American Crime Story: Rawhide Down
Score: +1
Ryan Guzman
as Perry Smith in American Crime Story: In Cold Blood
Score: +1
Hunter Parrish
as Richard Hickock in American Crime Story: In Cold Blood
Score: +2
Jeremy Shada
as John Andrew Ramsey in American Crime Story: JonBenét
Score: +1
Landry Bender
as Melinda Ramsey in American Crime Story: JonBenét
Score: +1
Megan Charpentier
as Beth Ramsey in American Crime Story: JonBenét
Score: +3
John Lloyd Young
as Tom Koby in American Crime Story: JonBenét
Score: +2
Ted Levine
as Alex Hunter in American Crime Story: JonBenét
Score: +1
Steve Carell
as Fleet White in American Crime Story: JonBenét
Score: +1
John Cusack
as John Ramsey in American Crime Story: JonBenét
Score: +3
Jeremy Renner
as John Ramsey in American Crime Story: JonBenét
Score: +2
Denis O'Hare
as Lou Smit in American Crime Story: JonBenét
Score: +5
Clive Owen
as Mark Beckner in American Crime Story: JonBenét
Score: +2
Evan Peters
as Steve Thomas in American Crime Story: JonBenét
Score: +2
Melissa McCarthy
as Linda Hoffmann-Pugh in American Crime Story: JonBenét
Score: +2
John Goodman
as Bill McReynolds in American Crime Story: JonBenét
Score: +2
Peter Krause
as Michael Kane in American Crime Story: JonBenét
Score: +2
Anne Hathaway
as Patsy Ramsey in American Crime Story: JonBenét
Score: +2
Natalie Portman
as Patsy Ramsey in American Crime Story: JonBenét
Score: +3