Suggestions by @drivenslush

Milo Gibson

as Mason Walker in Where in the World is Karen Walker?

Score: +1

Melissa Benoist

as Olivia Walker in Where in the World is Karen Walker?

Score: +1

Augustine Frizzell

as Director in The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue

Score: 0

Maika Monroe

as Zhered-Na in Marvel's Dark Magic Corner

Score: +2

Rachel House

as Topaz in Marvel's Dark Magic Corner

Score: +1

Kenneth Branagh

as Director in Anne Boleyn

Score: +2

John Cena

as Taboo in Marvel's Dark Magic Corner

Score: +1

Evanna Lynch

as Satana in Marvel's Dark Magic Corner

Score: +1

Maisie Richardson-Sellers

as Pandemonia in Marvel's Dark Magic Corner

Score: +1

Booboo Stewart

as Nicholas Scratch in Marvel's Dark Magic Corner

Score: +1

Gina Carano

as Mephista in Marvel's Dark Magic Corner

Score: +1

Laura Prepon

as Maria Russoff in Marvel's Dark Magic Corner

Score: +1

Carmen Ejogo

as Margali Szardos in Marvel's Dark Magic Corner

Score: +1

Sterling K. Brown

as Klonus in Marvel's Dark Magic Corner

Score: +1

Jen Landon

as Katherine Reynolds in Marvel's Dark Magic Corner

Score: +1

Maya Stojan

as Kara in Marvel's Dark Magic Corner

Score: +1

Jeremy Allen White

as Immortalis in Marvel's Dark Magic Corner

Score: +1

Mason Gooding

as Hellphyr in Marvel's Dark Magic Corner

Score: +1

Nicolas Cage

as Ghost Rider in Marvel's Dark Magic Corner

Score: +1

Rumer Willis

as Ereshkigal in Marvel's Dark Magic Corner

Score: +1