Suggestions by @dreamleader

Patrick Schwarzenegger

as Thomas in Tanks for the Memories

Score: +3

James P. Sullivan

as John Cena in Which characters would you like to see actors play in live-action

Score: +4

Gordon (Thomas and Friends)

as John Cena in Which characters would you like to see actors play in live-action

Score: +3

Henry (Thomas and Friends)

as Henry Cavill in Which characters would you like to see actors play in live-action

Score: +1

Thomas the Tank Engine

as Ben Schwartz in Which characters would you like to see actors play in live-action

Score: +2

James the Red Engine

as Hugh Jackman in Which characters would you like to see actors play in live-action

Score: +6

Edward (Thomas and Friends)

as Hugh Jackman in Which characters would you like to see actors play in live-action

Score: +1

Hugh Jackman

as Edward in No Snow for Thomas

Score: +1

Thomas the Tank Engine

as Bill Hader in Which characters would you like to see actors play live action/animated movies?

Score: +1

John Krasinski

as Thomas in Testing Testing,1,2,3

Score: +1

Melissa Benoist

as Rainbow Dash in Testing Testing,1,2,3

Score: +1

Hugh Jackman

as Edward in Testing Testing,1,2,3

Score: +3

Steve Zahn

as James in Testing Testing,1,2,3

Score: +2

Mike Myers

as Henry in Henry's Magic Box

Score: +1

Dakota Fanning

as Fluttershy in Tanks for the Memories

Score: +1

Gordon (Thomas and Friends)

as Dwayne Johnson in Which Characters would you like to see actors play in live Action

Score: +3

Thomas the Tank Engine

as Ryan Reynolds in Which Characters would you like to see actors play in live Action

Score: +1

Gordon (Thomas and Friends)

as Brendan Fraser in Which Characters would you like to see actors play in live Action

Score: +1

Fluttershy

as Dakota Fanning in Which Characters would you like to see actors play in live Action

Score: +1