Suggestions by @dreamleader

James the Red Engine

as Red in Characters as Taylor Swift Songs

Score: +2

Josh Hutcherson

as Thomas in Respect for Gordon

Score: +2

Jim Carrey

as Thomas in Respect for Gordon

Score: +1

Tom Cruise

as Thomas in Respect for Gordon

Score: +1

Rowan Atkinson

as James in Respect for Gordon

Score: +1

Justin Timberlake

as Thomas in Tanks for the Memories

Score: +1

Henry (Thomas and Friends)

as Robert De Niro in Which characters would you like to see actors play in live-action

Score: +2

Toby (Thomas and Friends)

as Robert De Niro in Which characters would you like to see actors play in live-action

Score: +1

Jay Baruchel

as Thomas in Tanks for the Memories

Score: +1

Joe Keery

as Thomas in Tanks for the Memories

Score: +1

Ed Helms

as James in Fame and Misfortune

Score: +1

Ed Helms

as James in Tanks for the Memories

Score: +1

Kiernan Shipka

as Applejack in The Best Night Ever

Score: +3

Rainbow Dash

as Melissa Benoist in Actors and Actresses who should play Characters in Live Action

Score: +1

Rainbow Dash

as Melissa Benoist in Which Characters Would You Like To See Actors Play In Live Action

Score: +1

Rainbow Dash

as Melissa Benoist in Which characters would you like to see actors play in live-action

Score: +1

Rainbow Dash

as Melissa Benoist in Which Characters would you like to see actors play in live Action

Score: +1

Emilia Clarke

as Rarity in The Best Night Ever

Score: +1

Jessica Henwick

as Rarity in The Best Night Ever

Score: +2

Rebecca Ferguson

as Rarity in The Best Night Ever

Score: +1