Suggestions by @divyakohli

Rodrigo Santoro

as Bevier in The Elenium

Score: 0

Sina Najafi

as Talen in The Elenium

Score: +1

Amrita Acharia

as Sephrenia in The Elenium

Score: +1

Sean Bean

as Sparhawk in The Elenium

Score: +4

Liam Neeson

as Kurik in The Elenium

Score: +1

Lance Henriksen

as Yarris in The Elenium

Score: +1

Kara Hayward

as Porrim Maryam in Homestuck

Score: -13

Aubrey K. Miller

as Vriska Serket in Homestuck

Score: -17

Aubrey K. Miller

as Terezi Pyrope in Homestuck

Score: -13

Rowan Blanchard

as Nepeta Leijon in Homestuck

Score: +9

Colin Ford

as BRO Dirk in Homestuck

Score: -8

Reese Witherspoon

as MOM Roxy in Homestuck

Score: -4

Jude Law

as DAD in Homestuck

Score: -5

Gavin Casalegno

as Dirk Strider in Homestuck

Score: -15

Dylan Schmid

as Jake English in Homestuck

Score: -19

Anthony Keyvan

as Jake English in Homestuck

Score: -17

Peyton List

as Roxy Lalonde in Homestuck

Score: -16

Ryan Whitney

as Jane Crocker in Homestuck

Score: -22

CJ Adams

as Dave Strider in Homestuck

Score: -24

Isabella Kai

as Rose Lalonde in Homestuck

Score: -26