Suggestions by @diannaagronsgf
330 suggestions
Hunter Schafer
as Winter Anderson in American Horror Story Recast
Richard Harmon
as Kai Anderson in American Horror Story Recast
Michelle Trachtenberg
as Ivy Mayfair-Richards in American Horror Story Recast
Shay Mitchell
as Ally Mayfair-Richards in American Horror Story Recast
Joshua Rush
as Edward Phillipe Mott/ Rory Monahan in American Horror Story Recast
Gabrielle Union
as Monet Tumusiime/ Lee Haris in American Horror Story Recast
Jada Pinkett Smith
as Lee Harris in American Horror Story Recast
Darren Criss
as Sidney Aaron James in American Horror Story Recast
Mason Gooding
as Dominic Banks in American Horror Story Recast
LaKeith Stanfield
as Matt Miller in American Horror Story Recast
Gillian Jacobs
as Shelby Miller in American Horror Story Recast
Katherine Heigl
as Dr. Alex Lowe in American Horror Story Recast
Teyonah Parris
as Ramona Royale in American Horror Story Recast
Manny Jacinto
as Tristan Duffy in American Horror Story Recast
Pedro Pascal
as John Lowe in American Horror Story Recast
Donald Glover
as Donovan in American Horror Story Recast
Eva Green
as Hypodermic Sally in American Horror Story Recast
Alexa Demie
as The Countess in American Horror Story Recast
Marisa Tomei
as Hazel Evers in American Horror Story Recast
Max Greenfield
as Will Drake in American Horror Story Recast