Suggestions by @derpenstein

Christina Hendricks

as Michelle Payne in Max Payne

Score: +2

Sean Bean

as Angelo Punchinello in Max Payne

Score: +1

Adrian Rayment

as Virgilio Finito in Max Payne

Score: +1

Neil Rayment

as Joey Finito in Max Payne

Score: +1

Ben Barnes

as Max Payne in Max Payne

Score: -3

Anthony Carrigan

as Richter in Hotline Miami

Score: +1

Andre Braugher

as Chief in Hotline Miami

Score: +1

Mark Boone Junior

as Burn in Hotline Miami

Score: +1

Steve Buscemi

as Rouven Blankenfeld in Hotline Miami

Score: 0

Olivia Wilde

as Sharon Wright in Hotline Miami

Score: +1

Mathilde Ollivier

as The Girl in Hotline Miami

Score: +1

Wyatt Russell

as Johnson in Hotline Miami

Score: +2

Boyd Holbrook

as Manny Pardo in Hotline Miami

Score: +1

Mark Ruffalo

as Evan Wright in Hotline Miami

Score: +1

Tony Curran

as Petrov in Hotline Miami

Score: +1

Mike Colter

as Jones in Hotline Miami

Score: +1

Charlie Heaton

as The Biker in Hotline Miami

Score: 0

David Harbour

as Aubrey in Hotline Miami

Score: +1

Robert De Niro

as Ivan Lebedev in Hotline Miami

Score: +1

Ben Barnes

as The Son in Hotline Miami

Score: +1