Suggestions by @darthsebastian

Rose McIver

as Mattie Landor in The Pale Blue Eye (2012)

Score: +1

Karl Urban

as 2024 2035 in Actors who would play John Wick in different decades

Score: +1

Hugh Jackman

as 2024 2035 in Actors who would play John Wick in different decades

Score: +1

Frances O'Connor

as Jennifer Cross in The Place Beyond the Pines (2002)

Score: +1

Paul Walker

as Luke Glanton in The Place Beyond the Pines (2002)

Score: +2

Frankie Muniz

as Michelangelo in Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (2000)

Score: +3

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Donatello in Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (2000)

Score: +4

Heath Ledger

as Raphael in Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (2000)

Score: +4

Hayden Christensen

as Leonardo in Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (2000)

Score: +2

Samuel L. Jackson

as Reginald in Night at the Museum trilogy (2016-2024)

Score: +6

Sam Claflin

as Lancelot in Night at the Museum trilogy (2016-2024)

Score: +4

Nicholas Hoult

as Lancelot in Night at the Museum trilogy (2016-2024)

Score: +4

Jonathan Bailey

as Octavius in Night at the Museum trilogy (2016-2024)

Score: +3

Glen Powell

as Jedediah in Night at the Museum trilogy (2016-2024)

Score: +4

Brad Pitt

as Bolt in Bolt (2008)

Score: +6

Elizabeth Olsen

as Laurie Jupiter/Silk Spectre II in Watchmen (2019)

Score: +1

Angelina Jolie

as Sally Jupiter/Silk Spectre in Watchmen (2019)

Score: +1

Bill Skarsgård

as Adrian Veidt/Ozymandias in Watchmen (2019)

Score: +1

Mel Gibson

as Shadow the Hedgehog in Sonic the Hedgehog Trilogy (2000-2004)

Score: -1

Samuel L. Jackson

as Knuckles the Echidna in Sonic the Hedgehog Trilogy (2000-2004)

Score: +5