Suggestions by @darthcroissant

Alexander Ludwig

as Scythe Chomsky in Scythe

Score: +2

Natasha Liu Bordizzo

as Scythe Rand in Scythe

Score: 0

Iñaki Godoy

as Tyger Salazar in Scythe

Score: +1

John Goodman

as High Blade Xenocrates in Scythe

Score: +3

Oscar Isaac

as Scythe Goddard in Scythe

Score: +4

Steve Carrell

as Scythe Faraday in Scythe

Score: -1

Alexander James Rodriguez

as Rowan Damisch in Scythe

Score: 0

Malia Baker

as Citra Terranova in Scythe

Score: +1

Mary Stuart Masterson

as Scythe Meir in Scythe

Score: +1

Piper Rubio

as Esme in Scythe

Score: +1

Ava Kolker

as Rhonda Flowers in Scythe

Score: +1

Clark Gregg

as The Businessman in Scythe

Score: +1

Michael Donovan

as Maxim Easley in Scythe

Score: +1

Genevieve O'Reilly

as Scythe Curie in Scythe

Score: +1

Neal Shusterman

as Scythe Mandela in Scythe

Score: +1

Janis Ahern

as Scythe Curie in Scythe

Score: -1

Alexander James Rodriguez

as Rowan Damisch in Scythe

Score: +1

Malia Baker

as Citra Terranova in Scythe

Score: +1

Gabriel Bateman

as Rowan Damisch in Scythe

Score: -1

Ben Mendelsohn

as Captain Beatty in Fahrenheit 451

Score: 0