Suggestions by @darth_conquer

Alex Pettyfer

as Fred Jones in Actors and Actresses, I'd Cast as these characters

Score: +1

Corey Burton

as Hugo Strange in My favorite Voices for these comic characters

Score: +1

Peter MacNicol

as Mad Hatter in My favorite Voices for these comic characters

Score: +1

Tasia Valenza

as Poison Ivy in My favorite Voices for these comic characters

Score: +1

Kevin Conroy

as Hush in My favorite Voices for these comic characters

Score: +1

Kevin Connolly

as Hush in My favorite Voices for these comic characters

Score: -1

Steve Blum

as Killer Croc in My favorite Voices for these comic characters

Score: -1

Stana Katic

as Talia Al Ghul in My favorite Voices for these comic characters

Score: +1

Tom Kane

as Quincy Sharp in My favorite Voices for these comic characters

Score: +1

James Horan

as Jayck Ryder in My favorite Voices for these comic characters

Score: +1

Duane R. Shepard Sr.

as Aaron Cash in My favorite Voices for these comic characters

Score: +1

Kari Wahlgren

as Vickie Vale in My favorite Voices for these comic characters

Score: +1

Khary Payton

as Azrael (Michael Lane) in My favorite Voices for these comic characters

Score: +1

Grey DeLisle

as Catwoman in My favorite Voices for these comic characters

Score: +1

Dee Bradley Baker

as Ra's Al Ghul in My favorite Voices for these comic characters

Score: +1

Fred Tatasciore

as Bane in My favorite Voices for these comic characters

Score: +1

Ron Perlman

as Clayface in My favorite Voices for these comic characters

Score: +1

Jensen Ackles

as Red Hood in My favorite Voices for these comic characters

Score: +1

Tom Everett Scott

as Booster Gold in My favorite Voices for these comic characters

Score: +1

Johnathan Banks

as Commissioner Gordon in My favorite Voices for these comic characters

Score: +1