Suggestions by @dark

Ryan Phillippe

as Belzenlok in Magic: Origins

Score: +2

Willem Dafoe

as Razaketh in Magic: Origins

Score: 0

Woody Harrelson

as Kothophed in Magic: Origins

Score: +1

Dennis Quaid

as Griselbrand in Magic: Origins

Score: +1

Liam Neeson

as Alhammarret in Magic: Origins

Score: +2

Richard Madden

as Gideon in Magic: Origins

Score: +4

Jonny Weston

as Gideon in Magic: Origins

Score: 0

India Eisley

as Nissa in Magic: Origins

Score: +7

Samantha Barks

as Chandra in Magic: Origins

Score: +1

Julianne Hough

as Lilliana in Magic: Origins

Score: +1

Josh Hutcherson

as Jace in Magic: Origins

Score: 0

James Newton Howard

as Composer in Magic: Origins

Score: +1

Christopher Markus

as Writer in Magic: Origins

Score: +1

Andrew Adamson

as Director in Magic: Origins

Score: +1

Aaron Sorkin

as Producer in Magic: Origins

Score: +1

Philippa Boyens

as Writer in Magic: Origins

Score: 0