Suggestions by @danthefan28

David Lynch

as Jim Gordon in David Lynch’s Batman Duology (1989-1992)

Score: +2

Bill Irwin

as Gandalf in Christopher Nolan's The Lord of the Rings Trilogy

Score: +1

Jack Quaid

as Beak in X-Men

Score: +2

Teyana Taylor

as Angel Salvadore in X-Men

Score: +4

Úrsula Corberó

as Callisto in X-Men

Score: +4

Ewan Mitchell

as Arcade in X-Men

Score: +1

Sophia Lillis

as Wolfsbane in X-Men

Score: 0

Amber Midthunder

as Mirage in X-Men

Score: +4

Bo Burnham

as Deadpool in X-Men

Score: +4

Ana de Armas

as Domino in X-Men

Score: +4

Eduardo Noriega

as The Creature in Frankenstein (1995)

Score: +2

David Dastmalchian

as Joker in Absolute Batman

Score: 0

Tessa Thompson

as Selina Kyle in Absolute Batman

Score: -2

Oded Fehr

as Alfred Pennyworth in Absolute Batman

Score: +1

Dominic Sessa

as The Joker in The Dark Knight (2025)

Score: +1

George Miller

as Tarman in The Death Stranding Duology (1999-2005)

Score: +3

Ray Nicholson

as Blades in Dawn of the Dead

Score: +2

James Cagney

as The Riddler in Batman (1954)

Score: +1

Hedy Lamarr

as Catwoman in Batman (1954)

Score: +1

Orson Welles

as Jim Gordon in Batman (1954)

Score: +1