Suggestions by @danilostorto

Tyler Mane

as Umaro in Final Fantasy VI

Score: +2

Johnny Depp

as Setzer Gabbiani in Final Fantasy VI

Score: +3

Sophie Turner

as Celes Chere in Final Fantasy VI

Score: +13

Orlando Bloom

as Locke Cole in Final Fantasy VI

Score: +2

Emmy Rossum

as Terra Branford in Final Fantasy VI

Score: -1

Hayley Atwell

as Fujiko in Lupin the Third

Score: 0

Steve Martin

as Inspector Zenigata in Lupin the Third

Score: +1

Michael Fassbender

as Jigen in Lupin the Third

Score: 0

Ryan Gosling

as Lupin in Lupin the Third

Score: +1

Guy Ritchie

as Director in The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes

Score: +5

Marion Bailey

as Mrs. Hudson in The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes

Score: +1

Brendan Gleeson

as Charles Augustus Milverton in The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes

Score: +3

Michael Sheen

as Ispector G. Lestrade in The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes

Score: +8

Paul Anderson

as Colonel Sebastian Moran in The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes

Score: +10

Emma Watson

as Mary Morstan in The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes

Score: +1

Matthew Lewis

as Mycroft Holmes in The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes

Score: +1

Eva Green

as Irene Adler in The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes

Score: +11

Rupert Friend

as Professor James Moriarty in The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes

Score: -1

Rupert Grint

as Doctor John Hamish Watson in The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes

Score: -1

Josh O'Connor

as Sherlock Holmes in The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes

Score: -3