Suggestions by @danilostorto

Benjamin McKenzie

as Ben Mears in Salem's Lot

Score: -1

Ezra Miller

as John Lennon in The Beatles

Score: -5

Russell Crowe

as God in Lilith and Eve

Score: +2

Lenny Kravitz

as Satan in Lilith and Eve

Score: -1

Zachary Levi

as Adam in Lilith and Eve

Score: 0

Alice Eve

as Eve in Lilith and Eve

Score: -1

Cate Blanchett

as Lilith in Lilith and Eve

Score: 0

Dane DeHaan

as Morfin Gaunt in Voldemort : Origins

Score: +2

Jared Harris

as Albus Dumbledore in Voldemort : Origins

Score: +4

Joseph Fiennes

as Old Tom Riddle Sr. in Voldemort : Origins

Score: +4

Jack Gleeson

as Tom Marvolo Riddle Jr. in Voldemort : Origins

Score: -1

James Cromwell

as Headmaster Armando Dippet in Voldemort : Origins

Score: +1

Christina Ricci

as Merope Gaunt in Voldemort : Origins

Score: -1

James Mangold

as Director in Crossface - Chris Benoit Biopic

Score: +2

Harry Styles

as Shawn Michaels in Crossface - Chris Benoit Biopic

Score: +2

Jackson Rathbone

as Edge in Crossface - Chris Benoit Biopic

Score: 0

Tyler Posey

as Rey Mysterio in Crossface - Chris Benoit Biopic

Score: 0

Kellan Lutz

as Kurt Angle in Crossface - Chris Benoit Biopic

Score: +2

Alexander Ludwig

as Chris Jericho in Crossface - Chris Benoit Biopic

Score: +2

Alison Luff

as Nancy Benoit in Crossface - Chris Benoit Biopic

Score: 0