Suggestions by @danepeplinski
1,132 suggestions
Penn Badgley
as Jack Torrance in The Shining
Score: -1
Sophia Lillis
as Betsy Bell in The bell witch
Score: +1
Kate Dickie
as Lucy Bell in The bell witch
Score: +1
Don Cheadle
as Forrest in The Strange Thing About The Johnson’s (Feature Length)
Score: +1
Loretta Devine
as Joan Johnson in The Strange Thing About The Johnson’s (Feature Length)
Score: +2
Michael B. Jordan
as Isaiah in The Strange Thing About The Johnson’s (Feature Length)
Score: 0
John David Washington
as Isaiah in The Strange Thing About The Johnson’s (Feature Length)
Score: 0
Wesley Snipes
as Sidney Johnson in The Strange Thing About The Johnson’s (Feature Length)
Score: +1
Angela Bassett
as Joan Johnson in The Strange Thing About The Johnson’s (Feature Length)
Score: +2
Ari Aster
as Director in The Strange Thing About The Johnson’s (Feature Length)
Score: +1
Willem Dafoe
as The Giver in The Giver
Score: +2
Robert Eggers
as Director in The Giver
Score: +1
Helena Bonham Carter
as Miss Peregrine in Miss Peregrines Home for Peculiar Children
Score: 0
Danny Elfman
as Composer in Neil Gaiman's Coraline
Score: +1
Tim Burton
as Director in Sleepy Hollow (2023)
Score: +1
Lily-Rose Depp
as Katrina Van Tassel in Sleepy Hollow (2023)
Score: +2
Jenna Ortega
as Katrina Van Tassel in Sleepy Hollow (2023)
Score: +1
Maria Bakalova
as Morgan Doughty in American Crime Story: The Murdaugh Murders
Score: 0
Lucas Hedges
as Alex Murdaugh in American Crime Story: The Murdaugh Murders
Score: -1
Robin Bartlett
as Gloria Satterfield in American Crime Story: The Murdaugh Murders
Score: +2