Suggestions by @daeverythingfan
478 suggestions
William Katt
as Tommy Slater in Fear Street (story removed)
Score: +1
Sissy Spacek
as Cindy Berman in Fear Street (story removed)
Score: +1
Robby Benson
as Young Nick Goode in Fear Street (story removed)
Score: +1
Jodie Foster
as Ziggy Berman in Fear Street (story removed)
Score: +1
Chad Michael Murray
as Nurse Aaron Fraser in Horror Highway
Score: +1
Xolo Maridueña
as Chris Thornton in Scream VII (2026)(story removed)
Score: +1
China Anne McClain
as Jordyn James in Horror Highway
Score: +1
Molly Ringwald
as Cindy Berman in 2010s - 2020s Netflix Shows & Movies
Score: +1
Winona Ryder
as Ziggy Berman in 2010s - 2020s Netflix Shows & Movies
Score: +1
River Phoenix
as JJ Maybank in 2010s - 2020s Netflix Shows & Movies
Score: +2
Jill Schoelen
as Eleven in 2010s - 2020s Netflix Shows & Movies
Score: +1
Johnny Depp
as Mike Wheeler in 2010s - 2020s Netflix Shows & Movies
Score: +1
Skeet Ulrich
as Deputy William Carpenter in Horror Highway
Score: +1
D.J. Cotrona
as Sheriff Kyle Alvarez in Horror Highway
Score: +1
Jenna Ortega
as Rachel Todd in Horror Highway
Score: +1
Chase Stokes
as Alexander Roberts in Horror Highway
Score: +1
Jack Champion
as Angel Roberts in Horror Highway
Score: +1
Chris Evans
as A. Roberts in Horror Highway
Score: +1
Malachi Barton
as Connor Norton in Horror Highway
Score: +1
Sadie Sink
as Samantha Watkins in Horror Highway
Score: +1