Suggestions by @cutmanisback

Midget Apple/Little Apple (Annoying Orange)

as The Movie's Saving Grace in The Worst Christmas Movie

Score: +1

Pear (Annoying Orange)

as The REAL Main Villain in The WORST Batman Movie

Score: +4

Passion Fruit (Annoying Orange)

as Catwoman in The WORST Batman Movie

Score: +4

Fat Albert

as The Penguin in The WORST Batman Movie

Score: +3

Marshmallow (Annoying Orange)

as The Joker in The WORST Batman Movie

Score: +3

Johnny Test

as Post Credit Scene in Sense of Right Alliance vs The Smurfs

Score: +4

Gamera

as The Random Cameo in MyCast: Misfits and Heroes

Score: +1

Godzilla

as The Random Cameo in MyCast: Misfits and Heroes

Score: +2

Garfield

as The Random Cameo in MyCast: Misfits and Heroes

Score: -1

Brody Foxx

as Goldie in Rock-a-Doodle: WORSE EDITION

Score: +2

Woody Harrelson

as Jake from Free Birds in M&M's and The Revenge of Maya Rudolph

Score: +2

Stephen Sommers

as Director in Popeye

Score: +2

Robert Foxworth

as What if we fixed Transformers 4 & 5? in myFiction

Score: +8

Grey DeLisle

as What if we fixed Transformers 4 & 5? in myFiction

Score: +8

Bumblebee

as What if we fixed Transformers 4 & 5? in myFiction

Score: +7

Jak and Daxter (characters)

as The Movie's Saving Grace in The Worst Christmas Movie

Score: +2

Garfield A Tale of Two Kitties

as Movies in Movies that deserve a sequel

Score: +4

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Out of the Shadows

as Movies in Movies that deserve a sequel

Score: +2

Shia LaBeouf

as What if The Garfield movies were rebooted in the 2010s? in myFiction

Score: +3

Kurt Russell

as What if The Garfield movies were rebooted in the 2010s? in myFiction

Score: +4