Suggestions by @crystal424

Ian Harding

as Nick in Lock Every Door

Score: -1

Emilia Clarke

as Quincy in Final Girls

Score: -5

Barrett Wilbert Weed

as Connor Murphy in Dear Evan Hansen (Genderswap)

Score: -3

Kyle Selig

as Warren Huntington III in Legally Blonde Live

Score: +2

Sofia Carson

as Jules Larsen in Lock Every Door

Score: +2

Lea Michele

as Jules Larsen in Lock Every Door

Score: -5

Luna Blaise

as Young Jules in Lock Every Door

Score: -1

Mackenzie Foy

as Young Jules in Lock Every Door

Score: +4

Lucy Hale

as Jane in Lock Every Door

Score: +1

Emilia Clarke

as Jane in Lock Every Door

Score: +1

Lily Collins

as Jane in Lock Every Door

Score: +8

Kristine Froseth

as Snow White in Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs

Score: -5

Taissa Farmiga

as Snow White in Disney Princesses

Score: -49

Jesse Williams

as Nick in Lock Every Door

Score: -3

Emily Browning

as Ingrid in Lock Every Door

Score: +3

Derek Hough

as David in Behind Her Eyes

Score: -1

James Marsden

as David in Behind Her Eyes

Score: +2

Kaley Cuoco

as Louise in Behind Her Eyes

Score: -3

Megan Fox

as Adele in Behind Her Eyes

Score: +4

Meryl Streep

as Franny in The Last Time I Lied

Score: +5