Suggestions by @crystal424

Lily Collins

as Camilla in The Roanoke Girls

Score: +1

Odeya Rush

as Allegra in The Roanoke Girls

Score: 0

Kristine Froseth

as Lane in The Roanoke Girls

Score: +1

Jameela Jamil

as Sally in The Last Mrs. Parrish

Score: 0

Rachel McAdams

as Millicent in My Lovely Wife.

Score: -2

Bridget Regan

as Millicent in My Lovely Wife.

Score: +2

Naomi Scott

as Tahani Al-Jamil in The Good Place (2024)

Score: 0

Ariel Winter

as Jamie Sullivan (A Walk To Remember) in Not Another Romantic Movie

Score: +1

Shay Mitchell

as Miranda in One By One

Score: +2

Julianne Hough

as Ava in One By One

Score: -4

Emma Watson

as Jules in The Guest List

Score: -20

Steve Buscemi

as Rick Sanchez in Rick And Morty

Score: +1

Margot Robbie

as Galadriel in Characters who Margot Robbie should play in live-action movies

Score: +1

Sophia Lillis

as Agnes in Only ever yours

Score: +1

Noah Centineo

as Darwin in Only ever yours

Score: -1

Jessica Belkin

as Isabel in Only ever yours

Score: -1

Mackenzie Foy

as Megan in Only ever yours

Score: -2

Sabrina Carpenter

as Cara in Only ever yours

Score: +1

Zendaya

as Freida in Only ever yours

Score: +1

Jamie Chung

as Helen in His & Hers

Score: -2