Suggestions by @crowbus940

Triple H

as Bane in Alex Proyas's Batman Trilogy (2003-2009)

Score: +1

Michael C. Hall

as Riddler in Alex Proyas's Batman Trilogy (2003-2009)

Score: -1

Sam Rockwell

as Joker in Alex Proyas's Batman Trilogy (2003-2009)

Score: 0

Naomi Watts

as Vicky Vale in Alex Proyas's Batman Trilogy (2003-2009)

Score: +1

Charlize Theron

as Catwoman in Alex Proyas's Batman Trilogy (2003-2009)

Score: -1

Benicio del Toro

as 2000s Sage in Omens Comics Multiverse

Score: +1

Wolfgang Novogratz

as 2020's Edge in Omens Comics Multiverse

Score: +3

Justin Theroux

as Tek Knight in The Boys (2006-2012) Comic Accurate

Score: +3

Viggo Mortensen

as Soldier Boy in The Boys (2006-2012) Comic Accurate

Score: +2

Kyle MacLachlan

as Stan Edgar in The Boys (2006-2012) Comic Accurate

Score: +1

Julia Stiles

as Starlight in The Boys (2006-2012) Comic Accurate

Score: +1

Jean Dujardin

as Frenchy in The Boys (2006-2012) Comic Accurate

Score: +1

Denzel Washington

as Mother's Milk in The Boys (2006-2012) Comic Accurate

Score: +1

Chiaki Kuriyama

as The Female in The Boys (2006-2012) Comic Accurate

Score: +2

Shia LaBeouf

as Webweaver in The Boys (2006-2012) Comic Accurate

Score: +3

Jonathan Frakes

as Billy William Butcher in The Boys (2006-2012) Comic Accurate

Score: -1

Russell Crowe

as Thor in Marvel 2000s

Score: 0

John Stamos

as Iron-Man in Marvel 2000s

Score: -1

Seann William Scott

as Lamplighter in The Boys (2006-2012) Comic Accurate

Score: +1

Mark Valley

as Captain America in Marvel 2000s

Score: +3