Suggestions by @crispytoast
1,595 suggestions
Olivia Holt
as Kelly Valentine in Slender man
Natalie Alyn Lind
as Kelly Valentine in Slender man
Chloë Grace Moretz
as Kelly Valentine in Slender man
Madison Iseman
as Kelly Valentine in Slender man
Dove Cameron
as Kelly Valentine in Slender man
Sabrina Carpenter
as Kelly Valentine in Slender man
Peyton List
as Kelly Valentine in Slender man
Jenna Ortega
as Gabriella Rodrigo in Slender man
Isabela Merced
as Gabriella Rodrigo in Slender man
Auliʻi Cravalho
as Gabriella Rodrigo in Slender man
Victoria Justice
as Gabriella Rodrigo in Slender man
Sofia Carson
as Gabriella Rodrigo in Slender man
Anya Taylor-Joy
as Haylie Parks in Slender man
Elle Fanning
as Haylie Parks in Slender man
Kaya Scodelario
as Haylie Parks in Slender man
Mackenzie Foy
as Haylie Parks in Slender man
Joey King
as Haylie Parks in Slender man
Natalia Dyer
as Haylie Parks in Slender man
Maya Hawke
as Haylie Parks in Slender man
Bailee Madison
as Haylie Parks in Slender man