Suggestions by @crblankenship

Aaron Taylor-Johnson

as Beren in Beren and Luthien

Score: 0

Antonio Banderas

as Hérnan Cortez in Young Jack Sparrow

Score: +2

Spencer List

as Fitzwilliam P. Dalton III in Young Jack Sparrow

Score: +1

Greg sulkin

as Fitzwilliam P. Dalton III in Young Jack Sparrow

Score: +1

Keith Richards

as Captain Teague Sparrow in Young Jack Sparrow

Score: +2

Bill Skarsgård

as Bill Turner in Young Jack Sparrow

Score: +1

Thomas Doherty

as Bill Turner in Young Jack Sparrow

Score: +1

Daisy Ridley

as Arabella Smith in Young Jack Sparrow

Score: 0

Timothée Chalamet

as Jack Sparrow in Young Jack Sparrow

Score: +2

Cole Sprouse

as Jack Sparrow in Young Jack Sparrow

Score: +3

D'Pharaoh Woon-A-Tai

as Forge in MCU X-Men

Score: +3

Lucy Boynton

as Emma Frost in MCU X-Men

Score: +2

Lauren Lindsey Donzis

as Paris Kinney in MCU X-Men

Score: +1

Brendan Fraser

as Hank McCoy in MCU X-Men

Score: +1

Isabella Sermon

as Auma in Redwall

Score: +1

Dylan Llewellyn

as Saxtus in Redwall

Score: +1

Kevin Kline

as Captain Snow in Redwall

Score: +1

Dylan Llewellyn

as Pink Clockwork Soldier in Luigi’s Mansion (Live Action)

Score: +1

Devon Murray

as Green Clockwork Soldier in Luigi’s Mansion (Live Action)

Score: +1

Pedro Pascal

as John Churchmouse in Redwall

Score: +1