Suggestions by @crazycritter

Golshifteh Farahani

as Captain Al Ghul [Earth-31] in Elseworlds (S3) (2024)

Geraldine Viswanathan

as Doctor Multiverse/Maya Chamara [Earth-8] in Elseworlds (S3) (2024)

Natalia Dyer

as Mary Marvel/Mary Bromfield [Earth-S] in Elseworlds (S3) (2024)

Hayley Atwell

as Wonder Woman/Diana Of Themyscira [Earth-24] in Elseworlds (S3) (2024)

Michael B. Jordan

as President Superman/Calvin Ellis [Earth-23] in Elseworlds (S3) (2024)

Alexandra Daddario

as Zatanna Zatara [Earth-84] in Elseworlds (S3) (2024)

Katheryn Winnick

as Aquawoman/Ariel Curry [Earth-11] in Elseworlds (S3) (2024)

Melissa Benoist

as Supergirl/Kara Zor-El [Earth-14] in Elseworlds (S3) (2024)

Katheryn Winnick

as Aquawoman/Ariel Curry [Earth-11] in Elseworlds (S2) (2023)

Michael B. Jordan

as President Superman/Calvin Ellis [Earth-23] in Elseworlds (S2) (2023)

Alexandra Daddario

as Zatanna Zatara [Earth-84] in Elseworlds (S2) (2023)

Michael Fassbender

as The Spectre [Earth-84] in Elseworlds (S2) (2023)

Melissa Benoist

as Supergirl/Kara Zor-El [Earth-14] in Elseworlds (S2) (2023)

Hayley Atwell

as Wonderdon [Earth-27] in Elseworlds (S2) (2023)

Geraldine Viswanathan

as Doctor Multiverse/Maya Chamara [Earth-8] in Elseworlds (S2) (2023)

Richard Madden

as Prince Kal-El [Earth-118] in Elseworlds (S2) (2023)

Bryan Cranston

as Commissioner Gordon [Earth-43] in Elseworlds (S2) (2023)

Anthony Starr

as Count Dracula [Earth-43] in Elseworlds (S2) (2023)

Bob Odenkirk

as Uncle Sam/Sam Wilson [Earth-X] in Elseworlds (S2) (2023)

David Tennant

as The Riddler/Edward Nygma [Earth-92] in Elseworlds (S2) (2023)