Suggestions by @cottonswabs

Daniel Sharman

as Elliot in Love and Other Words

Score: +1

Grant Gustin

as Elliot in Love and Other Words

Score: +1

cindy mello

as Macy in Love and Other Words

Score: +1

Camila Queiroz

as Macy in Love and Other Words

Score: +1

Giullia Buscacio

as Macy in Love and Other Words

Score: +1

Bruna Marquezine

as Macy in Love and Other Words

Score: +1

Brenna D'Amico

as Alice in The Secret Circle Trilogy

Score: +1

Ryan Whitney

as Alice in The Secret Circle Trilogy

Score: -1

Grace Van Dien

as Bellatrix in The Secret Circle Trilogy

Score: +1

Kristine Froseth

as Alice in The Secret Circle Trilogy

Score: -1

Lizzy Greene

as Sally in The Secret Circle Trilogy

Score: +1

Kelly Gale

as Faye in The Secret Circle Trilogy

Score: +1

Drake Rodger

as Nick in The Secret Circle Trilogy

Score: +1

Xolo Maridueña

as Nick in The Secret Circle Trilogy

Score: -1

Tanner Buchanan

as Max in The Secret Circle Trilogy

Score: +1

Noah Centineo

as Max in The Secret Circle Trilogy

Score: -1

KJ Apa

as Max in The Secret Circle Trilogy

Score: -1

Jacob Elordi

as Max in The Secret Circle Trilogy

Score: -1

Cierra Ramirez

as Faye in The Secret Circle Trilogy

Score: -1

Fiona Palomo

as Faye in The Secret Circle Trilogy

Score: -1