Suggestions by @coolguy

Matt Damon

as Baird Whitlock in Hail, Caesar! (2022)

Score: +6

Tye Sheridan

as Hobie Doyle in Hail, Caesar! (2022)

Score: +4

Nicolas Cage

as Egghead in Every Batman Character

Score: +16

Julia Garner

as Helen Lyle in Candyman (2022)

Score: +2

Bill Hader

as Officer Gus Grimly in Fargo - Season 1 (2014)

Score: +4

Diane Guerrero

as Mystique in All the X-Men Characters

Score: -5

Mads Mikkelsen

as Mister Freeze in Actors Who Could Play Mister Freeze in a Batman Seuqel

Score: +8

Dave Bautista

as Professor Hugo Strange in Every Batman Character

Score: +8

Elizabeth Debicki

as Batman in The Batman: Rule 63

Score: +9

Stella Stocker

as Martha Wayne in Every Batman Character

Score: -1

Con O'Neill

as Mackenzie Bock in Every Batman Character

Score: 0

Justice Smith

as Riley Poole in National Treasure (2022-2025)

Score: 0

Billy Magnussen

as Peacemaker in The Suicide Squad

Score: +1

Christina Ricci

as Harley Quinn in The Suicide Squad

Score: +3

Jude Law

as Harry Waters in In Bruges (2018)

Score: +6

Michael Smiley

as Ken Daley in In Bruges (2018)

Score: +4

Barry Keoghan

as Ray in In Bruges (2018)

Score: +6

Domhnall Gleeson

as Ray in In Bruges (2018)

Score: +3

Harry Dean Stanton

as Pete Krumbein in Nightmare Alley (1984)

Score: +4

Holt McCallany

as Hammerhead in Spider-Man's Rogues Gallery

Score: +1