Suggestions by @conantalks

Thomas Haden Church

as Flint Marko in THE AMAZING SPIDER-MAN VS SPIDER-MAN (2018)

Score: +1

Andrew Garfield

as Peter Parker in THE AMAZING SPIDER-MAN VS SPIDER-MAN (2018)

Score: +1

Javier Bardem

as Dr. Otto Octavius in THE AMAZING SPIDER-MAN VS SPIDER-MAN (2018)

Score: +1

Benedict Cumberbatch

as Dr. Stephen Strange in THE AMAZING SPIDER-MAN VS SPIDER-MAN (2018)

Score: +1

Tobey Maguire

as Peter Parker 1 in ARMOR WARS (2023)

Score: -1

Ezra Miller

as Daren Feigh in SCREAM 6 (2024)

Score: +2

Jonathan Adams

as Frances Pimm in SCREAM 6 (2024)

Score: +1

Jenna Ortega

as Tara Carpenter in SCREAM 6 (2024)

Score: +1

Skeet Ulrich

as Billy Loomis in SCREAM 6 (2024)

Score: +2

Courtney Cox

as Gale Weathers in SCREAM 6 (2024)

Score: +2

David Arquette

as Dewey Riley in SCREAM 6 (2024)

Score: +3

Jasmin Savoy Brown

as Mindy Meeks-Martin in SCREAM 6 (2024)

Score: +1

Fiona Dourif

as Phyliss Macher in SCREAM 6 (2024)

Score: +2

Alexander Ludwig

as Dennis Novotny in SCREAM 6 (2024)

Score: +1

Matthew Lillard

as Stu Macher in SCREAM 6 (2024)

Score: +3

Evan Peters

as Joel Dorsey in SCREAM 6 (2024)

Score: +3

Melissa Barrera

as Sam Carpenter in SCREAM 6 (2024)

Score: +2

Isabelle Fuhrman

as Julissa Weathers in SCREAM 6 (2024)

Score: +2

Dylan O'Brien

as Milton Fane in SCREAM 6 (2024)

Score: +1

Teyonah Parris

as Sonya Pimm in SCREAM 6 (2024)

Score: +1