Suggestions by @conantalks

Andrew Garfield

as Peter Parker 2 in ARMOR WARS (2023)

Score: 0

Matthew Lillard

as Stu Macher in SCREAM 8 (2027)

Score: +5

Hayden Christensen

as Morris Quentineo in SCREAM 8 (2027)

Score: +1

Aubrey Plaza

as Gina Milray in SCREAM 8 (2027)

Score: +1

Ezra Miller

as Daren Feigh in SCREAM 8 (2027)

Score: +1

Vanessa Hudgens

as Alessia Monni in SCREAM 8 (2027)

Score: +1

Angelina Jolie

as Alexa Dolin in SCREAM 8 (2027)

Score: +2

Skeet Ulrich

as Billy Loomis in SCREAM 8 (2027)

Score: +4

Tyler James Williams

as Eli Perry in SCREAM 8 (2027)

Score: +1

Dan Aykroyd

as Joseph Dolin in SCREAM 8 (2027)

Score: 0

Willem Dafoe

as Officer Robert Fowler in SCREAM 8 (2027)

Score: +1

Fiona Dourif

as Phyliss Macher in SCREAM 8 (2027)

Score: +4

Chiwetel Ejiofor

as Stanley Hill in SCREAM 8 (2027)

Score: +1

Dave Franco

as Luis Quent in SCREAM 8 (2027)

Score: 0

Timothy Olyphant

as Brayden Feigh in SCREAM 8 (2027)

Score: +1

Lily James

as Emery Caldwell in SCREAM 8 (2027)

Score: +1

Jessica Chastain

as Stacy Fowler in SCREAM 8 (2027)

Score: +1

Jeremy Allen White

as Cal Bordeau in SCREAM 8 (2027)

Score: +7

Tom Holland

as Peter Parker in SPIDER-MAN 4: A New Hope (2023)

Score: +1

Aaron Taylor-Johnson

as Sergei Kravinoff in SPIDER-MAN 4: A New Hope (2023)

Score: +1