Suggestions by @comicboy

Margaret Qualley

as Charlie in Five nights at freddy's 3 (2019)

Matthew Lillard

as William Afton in Five nights at freddy's 3 (2019)

Mary Stuart Masterson

as Aunt Jen in Five nights at freddy's 3 (2019)

Denis Leary

as Officer Clay Burke in Five nights at freddy's 3 (2019)

RJ Cyler

as Lamar in Five nights at freddy's 3 (2019)

Keiynan Lonsdale

as Arty in Five Nights at freddy's 2 (2018)

Keiynan Lonsdale

as Arty in Five nights at freddy's 3 (2019)

keynan longsdale

as Arty in Five nights at freddy's 3 (2019)

Beanie Feldstein

as Marla in Five nights at freddy's 3 (2019)

Gabriel Basso

as Carlton in Five nights at freddy's 3 (2019)

Madison Iseman

as Jessica in Five nights at freddy's 3 (2019)

Nick Robinson

as John in Five nights at freddy's 3 (2019)

Tyler Burton Smith

as Writer in Five nights at freddy's 3 (2019)

Gil Kenan

as Director in Five nights at freddy's 3 (2019)

Tyler Burton Smith

as Writer in Five Nights at freddy's 2 (2018)

Gil Kenan

as Director in Five Nights at freddy's 2 (2018)

Matthew Lillard

as Springtrap in Five Nights at freddy's 2 (2018)

Henry Thomas

as Henry in Five Nights at freddy's 2 (2018)

Denis Leary

as Officer Clay Burke in Five Nights at freddy's 2 (2018)

Denis Leary

as Officer Burke in Five nights at Freddy's (2016)