Suggestions by @codypavilion

Jensen Ackles

as Samuel Huebner in Unearthly Possession (fictional)

Score: +1

Joseph Aolani

as Maui in Moana (live action remake)

Score: +1

Kyle and Tyler Price

as Gabe Duncan in Good Luck Charlie (remake)

Score: +2

Makalika Aloha Aolani

as Moana in Moana (live action remake)

Score: +1

Vino Oggs

as Deuce Martinez in Shake It Up (Disney Channel)

Score: +3

Jack Lawson Noatak

as Deuce Martinez in Shake It Up (Disney Channel)

Score: +2

Lucas Anthony Lowenthal

as Speed Racer (young) in Speed Racer (remake)

Score: +2

Cruzer Trip Cox

as Speed Racer (young) in Speed Racer (remake)

Score: +2

Augustus "Gus" Dean Morgan

as Sam Winchester in Supernatural Remake

Score: +2

Roman Joseph Karp

as District 5 Male in The Hunger Games Remake

Score: +1

D’Angelo Antonio Chavez

as Luke Skywalker in Star Wars 2

Score: +1

Arrow Rhodes Ackles

as Jessica Baker in Cheaper By The Dozen (and CBTD 2)

Score: +7

Ruby Rose Bouhalkoum

as Jessica Baker in Cheaper By The Dozen (and CBTD 2)

Score: -3

Salem Tyler Bouhalkoum

as Charlotte Duncan in Good Luck Charlie (remake)

Score: +2

Davis Cleveland

as Anakin Skywalker (19) in Star Wars 2

Score: +1

Matthew Kotmel

as Sam Winchester in Supernatural Remake

Score: +1

Charles Kotmel

as Sam Winchester in Supernatural Remake

Score: 0

Zeppelin Ackles

as Sam Winchester in Supernatural Remake

Score: +2

Anthony Tyler Cristo

as Sam Winchester in Supernatural Remake

Score: +2

Zeppelin Ackles

as Flynn Jones in Shake It Up (Disney Channel)

Score: +3