Suggestions by @christyeckert

Kiernan Shipka

as Mallory Quinn in Hidden Pictures

Score: 0

Sadie Sink

as Mallory Quinn in Hidden Pictures

Score: -4

Ben Robson

as Jonas in Only Love Can Hurt Like This

Score: -2

Austin Butler

as Anders in Only Love Can Hurt Like This

Score: -5

Suki Waterhouse

as Nadine in Only Love Can Hurt Like This

Score: -1

Imogen Poots

as Nadine in Only Love Can Hurt Like This

Score: -1

Alex Pettyfer

as Scott in Only Love Can Hurt Like This

Score: -1

Henry Golding

as Scott in Only Love Can Hurt Like This

Score: +1

Andrew Garfield

as Scott in Only Love Can Hurt Like This

Score: -1

India Eisley

as Bailey in Only Love Can Hurt Like This

Score: 0

Zoey Deutch

as Bailey in Only Love Can Hurt Like This

Score: -3

Natalia Dyer

as Bailey in Only Love Can Hurt Like This

Score: +3

Lily Collins

as Wren in Only Love Can Hurt Like This

Score: -1

Benjamin Hollingsworth

as Jonas in Only Love Can Hurt Like This

Score: -4

Luke Grimes

as Anders in Only Love Can Hurt Like This

Score: -2

Gal Gadot

as Katherine in The House Across The Lake

Score: -9

Margot Robbie

as Katherine in The House Across The Lake

Score: -5

Emilia Clarke

as Casey in The House Across The Lake

Score: +3

Elizabeth Olsen

as Casey in The House Across The Lake

Score: +11

Alexandra Daddario

as Casey in The House Across The Lake

Score: -9