Suggestions by @christyeckert

Luke Bracey

as Jake Danner in Can’t Look Away

Elisabeth Olsen

as Molly O’Neil in Can’t Look Away

Imogen Poots

as Molly O’Neil in Can’t Look Away

Lily James

as Molly O’Neil in Can’t Look Away

Laura Haddock

as Emma in The Girl Before

Emily Browning

as Jane in The Girl Before

Patrick Schwarzenegger

as Nico in Reckless Girls

Josephine Langford

as Lux in Reckless Girls

Kekoa Kekumano

as Nico in Reckless Girls

Jacob Elordi

as Scotty in Reminders Of Him

Taron Egerton

as Ledger in Reminders Of Him

Victoria Pedretti

as Kenna Rowan in Reminders Of Him

C.J. Thomason

as Ledger Ward in Reminders Of Him

Caterina Scorsone

as Leland in 28 Summers

Greta Scarano

as Laya Marston in The Last Post

Felicity Jones

as Melissa Evans in The Last Post

Zooey Deschanel

as Melissa Evans in The Last Post

Dylan O'Brien

as Micah Evans in The Last Post

Justin Chatwin

as Micah Evans in The Last Post

Liam Hemsworth

as Cameron Bennett in The Last Post