Suggestions by @chrisstraub

Lucas Hedges

as Cyclops in X-Men (MCU)

Score: -19

Leonardo DiCaprio

as Wolverine in X-Men (MCU)

Score: -33

Alexandra Shipp

as Storm in X-Men (MCU)

Score: -8

Shailene Woodley

as Rogue in X-Men (MCU)

Score: -23

Jude Law

as The Nice Man in Imaginary Friend

Score: +1

Frances Conroy

as The Hissing Lady in Imaginary Friend

Score: +3

Carrie Coon

as Kate Reese in Imaginary Friend

Score: 0

Jude Hill

as Christopher Reese in Imaginary Friend

Score: +1

Drew Goddard

as Writer in Project Hail Mary

Score: +2

Ken Kao

as Producer in Project Hail Mary

Score: +1

Phil Lord and Christopher Miller

as Director in Project Hail Mary

Score: +5

Zac Efron

as Steve Hatch in Project Hail Mary

Score: -1

Denis Villeneuve

as Director in Project Hail Mary

Score: +5

Rhys Darby

as Bob Redell in Project Hail Mary

Score: +6

Taika Waititi

as Bob Redell in Project Hail Mary

Score: +4

Adam Scott

as Ryland Grace in Project Hail Mary

Score: -3

Adam McKay

as Director in Project Hail Mary

Score: -2