Suggestions by @chrisgilvar

Yuri Lowenthal

as Hometown Huck in Thumb Wrestling Federation

Score: +1

Greg Cipes

as Hometown Huck in Thumb Wrestling Federation

Score: +1

Todd Haberkorn

as Face-Off Phil in Thumb Wrestling Federation

Score: -1

Harland Williams

as Face-Off Phil in Thumb Wrestling Federation

Score: +1

David Kaye

as Gogachog in Thumb Wrestling Federation

Score: 0

John DiMaggio

as Gogachog in Thumb Wrestling Federation

Score: -1

John Dixon

as Gogachog in Thumb Wrestling Federation

Score: -2

Michael Dorn

as The Big Time in Thumb Wrestling Federation

Score: +1

Maurice LaMarche

as Sir Serpent in Thumb Wrestling Federation

Score: +1

Bumper Robinson

as Unit 19G in Thumb Wrestling Federation

Score: +1

Travis Willingham

as Vini Vidi Victory in Thumb Wrestling Federation

Score: +1

Travis Wright

as Vini Vidi Victory in Thumb Wrestling Federation

Score: -1

Maurice LaMarche

as Senator Skull in Thumb Wrestling Federation

Score: -1

Billy West

as Snagglefangs in Thumb Wrestling Federation

Score: -1

Rob Paulsen

as Rolf the Reaper in Thumb Wrestling Federation

Score: +1

Rodger Bumpass

as The Visitor in Thumb Wrestling Federation

Score: +1

Jeff Bennett

as The Visitor in Thumb Wrestling Federation

Score: +1

Kate Higgins

as Pei Pei the Purple Panda in Thumb Wrestling Federation

Score: +1

Lauren Tom

as Pei Pei the Purple Panda in Thumb Wrestling Federation

Score: +1

Tara Strong

as Mahi Mahi Mindy in Thumb Wrestling Federation

Score: +2