Suggestions by @chrisdeaver

Ben Schwartz

as Spongebob Squarepants in The Spongebob Movie: Rise Of Mister Sinister

Score: +3

Thanos

as Meet & Greets in Thanos Trick Or Treat Bash

Score: +3

Pinhead (Hellraiser)

as Meet & Greets in Thanos Trick Or Treat Bash

Score: +1

Leatherface

as Meet & Greets in Thanos Trick Or Treat Bash

Score: +2

Jigsaw (Saw)

as Meet & Greets in Thanos Trick Or Treat Bash

Score: +1

Chucky (Child's Play)

as Meet & Greets in Thanos Trick Or Treat Bash

Score: +2

Pennywise (It)

as Meet & Greets in Thanos Trick Or Treat Bash

Score: +3

Michael Myers

as Meet & Greets in Thanos Trick Or Treat Bash

Score: +2

Jason Voorhees

as Meet & Greets in Thanos Trick Or Treat Bash

Score: +1

Freddy Krueger

as Meet & Greets in Thanos Trick Or Treat Bash

Score: +1

Peter Parker/Spider-Man (Raimiverse)

as Meet & Greets in Thanos Trick Or Treat Bash

Score: +1

The Incredible Hulk

as Meet & Greets in Thanos Trick Or Treat Bash

Score: +1

Captain America (Marvel Cinematic Universe)

as Meet & Greets in Thanos Trick Or Treat Bash

Score: +1

Iron Man (Marvel Cinematic Universe)

as Meet & Greets in Thanos Trick Or Treat Bash

Score: +1

Danny Phantom

as Meet & Greets in Thanos Trick Or Treat Bash

Score: +2

Patrick Star

as Meet & Greets in Thanos Trick Or Treat Bash

Score: +1

SpongeBob SquarePants

as Meet & Greets in Thanos Trick Or Treat Bash

Score: +1

Rosearik Rikki Simons

as GIR in The LEGO Movie 3: A Galactic Adventure

Score: +1

Mia Talerico

as Bubbles in The LEGO Movie 3: A Galactic Adventure

Score: +3

Millie Bobby Brown

as Buttercup in The LEGO Movie 3: A Galactic Adventure

Score: +2