Suggestions by @chrisdeaver

Eric Jacobson

as Duck Guy in Don't Hug Me I'm Scared

Score: +3

Matt Vogel

as Red Guy in Don't Hug Me I'm Scared

Score: +1

Ryan Dillon

as Yellow Guy in Don't Hug Me I'm Scared

Score: +3

Becky Sloan

as Director in Don't Hug Me I'm Scared

Score: +3

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Tony The Talking Clock in Pony Perverts

Score: +2

Seth MacFarlane

as Brian Griffin in Pony Perverts

Score: +2

Po

as Teletubbies in Pony Perverts

Score: +4

Laa-Laa

as Teletubbies in Pony Perverts

Score: +4

Dipsy

as Teletubbies in Pony Perverts

Score: +4

Tinky-Winky

as Teletubbies in Pony Perverts

Score: +3

Trey Parker

as Michael Bay in Pony Perverts

Score: +3

Tom Holland

as Spider-Man in Pony Perverts

Score: +2

Idina Menzel

as Elsa in Pony Perverts

Score: +1

Harley Bird

as Peppa Pig in Pony Perverts

Score: +2

Tom Kenny

as Roger Rabbit in Pony Perverts

Score: +2

Steve Whitmire

as Kermit The Frog in Pony Perverts

Score: +2

Traci Paige Johnson

as Blue in Pony Perverts

Score: +3

Mark Hamill

as Buddi in Pony Perverts

Score: +2

Candi Milo

as Coco in Pony Perverts

Score: +2

Tom Kenny

as Eduardo in Pony Perverts

Score: +2