Suggestions by @chrisbaker

Richard Madden

as Superman in Injustice

Score: +1

Gary Oldman

as Professor Moriarty in League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Score: +2

Kenneth Branagh

as A. J. Raffles in League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Score: +1

Cillian Murphy

as Thomas Carnacki in League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Score: +1

Daniel Radcliffe

as Hutchinson Hatch in League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Score: +1

David Thewlis

as Professor Van Dusen in League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Score: +1

Eva Green

as Emma Peel in League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Score: +1

Priyanka Chopra Jonas

as Janni Dakkar in League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Score: +2

Laurence Fishburne

as Professor Van Dusen in League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Score: +1

Karl Urban

as John Ashleigh in League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Score: +1

Bryan Cranston

as Professor Moriarty in League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Score: +1

Giancarlo Esposito

as Prospero in League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Score: +1

Javier Bardem

as Don Quixote in League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Score: +1

Lee Pace

as Dorian Gray in League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Score: +1

Riz Ahmed

as Captain Nemo in League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Score: +1

Jeremy Irons

as Allan Quatermain in League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Score: +1

Timothée Chalamet

as Tom Sawyer in League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Score: +1

Idris Elba

as Dr. Jekyll in League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Score: +1

Aaron Taylor-Johnson

as Hawley Griffin in League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Score: +1

Rose Byrne

as Wilhelmina Murray in League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Score: +2