Suggestions by @chris83

Melissa McKendrick

as Joanna Going in Which characters should actors have played in the 80’s?

Joanna Going

as Soap Opera Stars in Face Claims Sorted by the '80s

John Loprieno

as Caleb Rivers in Pretty Little Liars (1980s)

Andy and Kyle

as Horror Movie Duos in Best Couples and Duos

Andy and Kyle

as Trauma Bond in Fictional Character Pairings

Andy and Kyle

as Duo with the Most Heartfelt Friendship in Fictional Character Pairings

Andy and Kyle

as Sibling Dynamic in Fictional Character Pairings

Andy and Kyle

as Childhood Friends in Fictional Character Pairings

Andy and Kyle

as Best Friends in Fictional Character Pairings

Andy and Kyle

as Friends in Fictional Character Pairings

Andy and Kyle

as Like Brother and Sister in Fictional Character Pairings

Aly Michalka

as Hannah Turman in Scream 7 (2006)

Faith MacCaullay

as Final Girl in Sort by Tropes

Faith MacCaullay

as 2020s in Final Girls by Decade

Alison Sweeney

as Buttercup in The Princess Bride (1997)

Keri Russell

as Buttercup in The Princess Bride (1997)

Amy Smart

as Buttercup in The Princess Bride (1997)

Marley Shelton

as Buttercup in The Princess Bride (1997)

Reese Witherspoon

as Buttercup in The Princess Bride (1997)

Kate Winslet

as Buttercup in The Princess Bride (1997)