Suggestions by @chesspiece99

Jeremy Culhane

as Stanley Ipkiss in The Mask (Horror Movie)

Score: +1

Persephone Valentine

as The Cheshire Cat in Dropout Presents: Alice in Wonderland

Score: +1

Lou Wilson

as The Cheshire Cat in Dropout Presents: Alice in Wonderland

Score: +1

Persephone Valentine

as Queen of Hearts in Dropout Presents: Alice in Wonderland

Score: +1

Jasmine Bhullar

as The Duchess in Dropout Presents: Alice in Wonderland

Score: +1

Persephone Valentine

as The Duchess in Dropout Presents: Alice in Wonderland

Score: +1

Jon Matteson

as Luigi in Mario (Starkid)

Score: +1

Jim Povolo

as Bowser in Mario (Starkid)

Score: +1

Jim Povolo

as Robbie Valentino in Gravity Falls- Starkid Addition

Score: +1

Jaime Lyn Beatty

as Wendy Corduroy in Gravity Falls- Starkid Addition

Score: +1

Lauren Lopez

as Mabel Pines in Gravity Falls- Starkid Addition

Score: +1

Ian Hecox

as YouTubers/Internet Personalities in Celebrities You’d Love to See on Hot Ones

Score: +1

Ian Hecox and Anthony Padilla

as YouTubers/Internet Personalities in Celebrities You’d Love to See on Hot Ones

Score: +2

Vic Michaelis

as YouTubers/Internet Personalities in Celebrities You’d Love to See on Hot Ones

Score: +2

Ify Nwadiwe

as The Fix in Mentopolis: The Movie

Score: +2

Ian Hecox

as Joey Sneezes in Mentopolis: The Movie

Score: +1

Jeremy Culhane

as Joey Sneezes in Mentopolis: The Movie

Score: +2

Jessica Chastain

as Imelda Pulse in Mentopolis: The Movie

Score: +1

Grant Gustin

as Tommy Bowe in The Smosh Story

Score: +1

Nicholas Braun

as Andy Kaufman in The Story of Saturday Night Live

Score: +2