Suggestions by @cherry_ice_fangirl

Karen Black

as Missy Armitage in Get Out (1987)

Score: +1

Miguel A. Núñez Jr.

as Chris Washington in Get Out (1987)

Score: 0

Miguel A. Núñez Jr.

as Chris Washington in Get Out (1987)

Score: +1

Kiefer Sutherland

as George LeBay in Cristine remake dream cast

Score: +1

Owen Teague

as Don Vandenberg in Cristine remake dream cast

Score: +1

Donald Sutherland

as Max in The Lost Boys (1977)

Score: +3

Andrea Martin

as Lucy Emerson in The Lost Boys (1977)

Score: +2

Keith Gordon

as Alan Frog in The Lost Boys (1977)

Score: +3

Shaun Cassidy

as Marko in The Lost Boys (1977)

Score: +3

William Katt

as Paul in The Lost Boys (1977)

Score: +3

Leif Garrett

as Sam Emerson in The Lost Boys (1977)

Score: +2

Marie Osmond

as Star in The Lost Boys (1977)

Score: +5

John Travolta

as David in The Lost Boys (1977)

Score: +4

Robby Benson

as Michael Emerson in The Lost Boys (1977)

Score: +4

Bill Moseley

as Ronald LeBay in Cristine remake dream cast

Score: +1

Deaken Bluman

as Buddy Repperton in Cristine remake dream cast

Score: +1

Lovie Simone

as Leigh Cabot in Cristine remake dream cast

Score: +1

Caleb McLaughlin

as Dennis Guilder in Cristine remake dream cast

Score: +1

Millicent Simmonds

as Moochie Welsh in Cristine remake dream cast

Score: +1

Sean Giambrone

as Arnie Cunningham in Cristine remake dream cast

Score: +1