Suggestions by @cheezypotatoes

Luke Evans

as Enji Todoroki in My Hero Academia (seasons 1-4)

Score: +5

John Cena

as Enji Todoroki in My Hero Academia (seasons 1-4)

Score: -1

Michael Fassbender

as Enji Todoroki in My Hero Academia (seasons 1-4)

Score: -1

Henry Cavill

as Enji Todoroki in My Hero Academia (seasons 1-4)

Score: +1

Jason Momoa

as Enji Todoroki in My Hero Academia (seasons 1-4)

Score: +2

David Harbour

as Enji Todoroki in My Hero Academia (seasons 1-4)

Score: +5

Margot Robbie

as Rumi Usagiyama in My Hero Academia (seasons 1-4)

Score: -2

Shailene Woodley

as Rumi Usagiyama in My Hero Academia (seasons 1-4)

Score: -1

Lili Reinhart

as Rumi Usagiyama in My Hero Academia (seasons 1-4)

Score: 0

Erin Moriarty

as Rumi Usagiyama in My Hero Academia (seasons 1-4)

Score: 0

Jeremy Irvine

as Keigo Takami in My Hero Academia (seasons 1-4)

Score: -2

Chris Colfer

as Keigo Takami in My Hero Academia (seasons 1-4)

Score: -6

Harry Styles

as Keigo Takami in My Hero Academia (seasons 1-4)

Score: -3

Tyler Posey

as Keigo Takami in My Hero Academia (seasons 1-4)

Score: -1

Ezra Miller

as Keigo Takami in My Hero Academia (seasons 1-4)

Score: -5

Lucas Till

as Keigo Takami in My Hero Academia (seasons 1-4)

Score: +2

Dacre Montgomery

as Keigo Takami in My Hero Academia (seasons 1-4)

Score: +1

Yuta Nakamoto

as Keigo Takami in My Hero Academia (seasons 1-4)

Score: -3

KJ Apa

as Rikido Sato in My Hero Academia (seasons 1-4)

Score: +1

Baran Onkol

as Rikido Sato in My Hero Academia (seasons 1-4)

Score: 0