Suggestions by @cheechgonzalez

Emma D'Arcy

as Jayde in Penance

Score: +2

Olivia Rodrigo

as Dolly in Penance

Score: +1

Garrett Hedlund

as Jamie Cleburne in Gothictown

Score: +1

Brec Bassinger

as Alice Tilton in Gothictown

Score: +1

Bade Arazlı

as Meredith Hope in Gothictown

Score: +1

Alex Pettyfer

as Peter Hope in Gothictown

Score: +1

Dianna Agron

as Billie Hope in Gothictown

Score: +1

Madeline Brewer

as Claire in Maeve Fly

Score: +1

Lucy Hale

as Wallis in Commonwealth: A Novel

Score: +1

Lily Cole

as Bonnie in Commonwealth: A Novel

Score: +1

Andrew Bachelor

as Lomer in Commonwealth: A Novel

Score: +1

Bryce Dallas Howard

as Teresa Cousins in Commonwealth: A Novel

Score: +1

Amanda Seyfried

as Beverly Keating in Commonwealth: A Novel

Score: +1

Joaquin Phoenix

as Young Albert Cousins in Commonwealth: A Novel

Score: +1

Jude Law

as Young Francis Xavier Keating in Commonwealth: A Novel

Score: +1

Angelina Jolie

as Frances Keating in Commonwealth: A Novel

Score: +1

Jon Voight

as Francis Xavier Keating in Commonwealth: A Novel

Score: +1

Alexandra Daddario

as Officer Pike in American Rapture

Score: +1

Audie Rick

as Wyatt in American Rapture

Score: +1

Grant Feely

as Wyatt in American Rapture

Score: +1