Suggestions by @charlesp

Jesse Plemons

as Professor Pyg in Professor Pyg

Score: +1

John Carroll Lynch

as Professor Pyg in Professor Pyg

Score: +4

Tom Hardy

as Chris Redfield in Resident Evil Village

Score: +2

Hayley Atwell

as Alcina Dimitrescu in Resident Evil Village

Score: +9

Isaiah Mustafa

as Lee Everett in Telltale’s The Walking Dead

Score: +46

Jane Levy

as Jena in American psycho

Score: +3

David Morrissey

as Colonel Sebastian Moran in The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes

Score: +2

Mark Korven

as Composer in The Shining

Score: +1

Lars Mikkelsen

as Count Orlok in Nosferatu: A Symphony of Horror

Score: -1

Morfydd Clark

as Mina Murray in Dracula BBC

Score: +4

Sam Raimi

as Director in 30 Days Of Night

Score: +1

James McAvoy

as Hellblazer in Deadman (2024)

Score: -1

Idris Elba

as Etrigan The Demon in Deadman (2024)

Score: +2

Vince Vaughn

as Kingpin in Top Comic Book Villains that deserve their own Solo Movie

Score: +1

Viggo Mortensen

as Magneto in Top Comic Book Villains that deserve their own Solo Movie

Score: +3

Tony Todd

as Doomsday in Top Comic Book Villains that deserve their own Solo Movie

Score: +2

Joel Edgerton

as Mr Freeze in Top Comic Book Villains that deserve their own Solo Movie

Score: +1

Anthony Hopkins

as Archbishop in Castlevania (2017) - Live action.

Score: +1

Keith David

as The Captain in Castlevania (2017) - Live action.

Score: +1

Mark Strong

as The Judge in Castlevania (2017) - Live action.

Score: +2