Suggestions by @charlesp

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Jack Torrance in Stephen king characters

Score: +4

James McAvoy

as John Constantine in Justice League Dark

Score: +1

Josh Brolin

as Hellboy in Hellboy: Seed of Destruction ( 2019 reboot )

Score: +1

Ian McKellen

as Professor Trevor Bruttenholm in Hellboy: Seed of Destruction ( 2019 reboot )

Score: +1

Zachary Quinto

as Abe Sapien in Hellboy: Seed of Destruction ( 2019 reboot )

Score: +1

Jack Nicholson

as 1980s Actor in Greatest Actor of Every Decade

Score: +5

Anthony Hopkins

as 1990s Actor in Greatest Actor of Every Decade

Score: +5

Ari Aster

as Director in Best Actors Of All Time

Score: +6

David Fincher

as Director in The Bat

Score: +1

Park Seo-jun

as Yong Sue in The Bat

Score: +2

Josefine Frida Pettersen

as Kristin in The Bat

Score: +1

Hugh Jackman

as Jim Connelly in The Bat

Score: +1

David Gulpilil

as Joseph Walter Roderigue in The Bat

Score: +1

Mark Coles Smith

as Robin Toowoomba in The Bat

Score: +1

Aaron Pedersen

as Andrew Kensington in The Bat

Score: +1

Kristine Froseth

as Inger Holter in The Bat

Score: +2

Salma Hayek Pinault

as Claudia Connelly in The Bat

Score: +1

Rebecca Ferguson

as Birgitta Enquist in The Bat

Score: +2

Eamon Farren

as Evans White in The Bat

Score: +1

Damon Herriman

as Sergey Lebie in The Bat

Score: +1