Suggestions by @chandlermchugh

Walton Goggins

as Ichabod Crane in Happily Ever After

Score: +1

Giancarlo Esposito

as Sidney Glass in Happily Ever After

Score: +1

Siena Agudong

as Moana in Happily Ever After

Score: 0

Lee Arenberg

as Leroy in Happily Ever After

Score: +1

Eion Bailey

as August Booth in Happily Ever After

Score: +1

Meghan Ory

as Ruby in Happily Ever After

Score: +1

Keegan Connor Tracy

as Mother Superior in Happily Ever After

Score: +2

Tony Amendola

as Marco in Happily Ever After

Score: +1

Raphael Sbarge

as Dr. Archie Hopper in Happily Ever After

Score: +1

Rebecca Mader

as Zelena in Happily Ever After

Score: +3

Lana Parrilla

as Regina Mills in Happily Ever After

Score: +2

Josh Dallas

as David Nolan in Happily Ever After

Score: +1

Ginnifer Goodwin

as Mary Margaret Blanchard in Happily Ever After

Score: +2

Alison Fernández

as Lucy Mills in Happily Ever After

Score: +1

Andrew J. West

as Henry Mills in Happily Ever After

Score: +1

Jamie Chung

as Mulan in Happily Ever After

Score: +2

Daniel Dae Kim

as Shan Yu in Happily Ever After

Score: +1

Jackie Hoffman

as Merryweather in Happily Ever After

Score: +1

Felicity Huffman

as Fauna in Happily Ever After

Score: +1

Jayne Atkinson

as Flora in Happily Ever After

Score: +1