Suggestions by @chancenorman

Alejandro (Total Drama)

as Prince Charming in Knuckles (Shrek) Quadrilogy

Score: +1

Ursula (The Little Mermaid)

as Fairy Godmother in Knuckles (Shrek) Quadrilogy

Score: -2

Mama Mario

as Queen Lillian in Knuckles (Shrek) Quadrilogy

Score: +1

Papa Mario

as Human King Harold in Knuckles (Shrek) Quadrilogy

Score: +2

Rayman

as Puss in Boots in Knuckles (Shrek) Quadrilogy

Score: +1

Mr. Peabody

as Magic Mirror in Knuckles (Shrek) Quadrilogy

Score: +1

Green Goblin (Marvel Cinematic Universe)

as Monsieur Hood in Knuckles (Shrek) Quadrilogy

Score: +1

Mickey, Donald, and Goofy

as Three Blind Mice in Knuckles (Shrek) Quadrilogy

Score: +1

Minions (Despicable Me)

as Three Little Pigs in Knuckles (Shrek) Quadrilogy

Score: +1

Scratch (The Ghost and Molly McGee)

as The Big Bad Wolf in Knuckles (Shrek) Quadrilogy

Score: +1

Sid the Sloth

as Pinocchio in Knuckles (Shrek) Quadrilogy

Score: +1

King Clawthorne

as Gingy in Knuckles (Shrek) Quadrilogy

Score: +1

Amy Rose

as The Dragon in Knuckles (Shrek) Quadrilogy

Score: +1

Amy Rose

as Queen Lilian in Knuckles (Shrek) Quadrilogy

Score: +1

Kronk

as Thelonious in Knuckles (Shrek) Quadrilogy

Score: +1

Aloysius O' Hare

as Lord Farquaad in Knuckles (Shrek) Quadrilogy

Score: +2

Mothra (MonsterVerse)

as Ogress Fiona in Knuckles (Shrek) Quadrilogy

Score: +1

Rumi (K-Pop Demon Hunters)

as Human Fiona in Knuckles (Shrek) Quadrilogy

Score: +1

Sonic the Hedgehog (Paramount)

as Donkey in Knuckles (Shrek) Quadrilogy

Score: +1

Godzilla (Monsterverse)

as Shrek in Knuckles (Shrek) Quadrilogy

Score: +1