Suggestions by @ccclarinet12

Jeremy Jordan

as Elder Price in The Book of Mormon

Kayla Pecchioni

as Nabalungi in The Book of Mormon

Newsies

as Best Broadway Musical in Best & Worst of Franchises

Eric Anderson

as Harold Zidler in Moulin Rouge!

Kara Lindsay

as Satine in Moulin Rouge!

Kayla Pecchioni

as Viola in & Juliet

Ryan Steele

as Thomas in & Juliet

Eric Anderson

as Sly in & Juliet

Jeff Kready

as Rumour in & Juliet

Thayne Jasperson

as Richard in & Juliet

Adrianna Hicks

as Nell in & Juliet

Annaleigh Ashford

as Margaret in & Juliet

Joy Woods

as Lucy in & Juliet

Ben Platt

as Kempe in & Juliet

Anne Boleyn (Six)

as Judith in & Juliet

Ariana Grande

as Imogen in & Juliet

Jack Black

as Henry in & Juliet

Samantha Pauly

as Gwynne in & Juliet

Leslie Odom Jr.

as Gregory in & Juliet

Ben Cook

as Fletcher in & Juliet