Suggestions by @cauedantas

Ian McKellen

as José Balaguer in Roman Ritual

Score: +2

Danny DeVito

as Aloisius in Roman Ritual

Score: +2

Willem Dafoe

as Georges in Roman Ritual

Score: +2

Sadie Sink

as The Ghost Girl in Roman Ritual

Score: +2

Anthony Hopkins

as The Pope in Roman Ritual

Score: +2

Jason Statham

as John Brennan in Roman Ritual

Score: +2

Joe Biden

as Funny Valentine in JoJo's Bizarre Adventure

Score: -3

Adam Sandler

as Star Platinum in JoJo's Bizarre Adventure

Score: -1

Zac Efron

as Funny Valentine in JoJo's Bizarre Adventure

Score: +3

Hugh Jackman

as Old Joseph in JoJo's Bizarre Adventure

Score: +1

Nicolas Cage

as Ben Grimm in The Fantastic Four

Score: -16