Suggestions by @cathexisarcana

Famke Janssen

as Phillipa Eilhart in The Witcher

Score: +22

Julie Benz

as Keira Metz in The Witcher

Score: -7

Brendan Gleeson

as Zoltan in The Witcher

Score: +18

Joshua Sasse

as Dandelion in The Witcher

Score: -4

Karen Gillan

as Triss Merigold in The Witcher

Score: +45

Janet Montgomery

as Yennefer of Vengerburg in The Witcher

Score: +19

Zach McGowan

as Geralt of Rivia in The Witcher

Score: -5

Bridgit Mendler

as April O'Neil in Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles

Score: -13

Ian Somerhalder

as Deacon Frost in Blade

Score: +7

Omari Hardwick

as Blade in Blade

Score: +7

Ron Perlman

as Ben Grimm in The Fantastic Four

Score: -14

Paula Patton

as Jennifer Walters in The Fantastic Four

Score: +4

Katheryn Winnick

as Sue Storm in The Fantastic Four

Score: -4

Naomi Scott

as Mina Murray in Dracula

Score: -5

Michelle Forbes

as Delilah Hack in Hack/Slash

Score: 0